Blogs

Northerners: The Political Untouchables

Published

3 years ago

June 27, 2021

‘Untouchables’ are the outcasts who live utterly alienated in the imposed social hierarchy perversely conspicuous in India, Pakistan, Nepal, and in some other countries. The more simplistic descriptions of the Indian caste system include the 4 major castes – Brahmins, Kshatriya, Vaishyas, and Shudras (in descending order) – and the fifth category of the untouchables or “Varna” who, unlike, foreigners or tribal people, were considered a part of “Samsara” but not having a “Varna” (place in the caste system).

Can this analysis of the caste system inform our understanding of the political question surrounding Gilgit-Baltistan? Aren’t the people of Gilgit-Baltistan politically outcasts, economically destitute, and constitutionally untouchables inside Pakistan’s political hierarchy?

The analogy fits very easily at one level, one has only to look at how the people of the country are classified in the configuration of territories under Pakistan’s administration i.e., four “constitutional” provinces along a hierarchy and the untouchables/scheduled tribes and castes of Gilgit-Baltistan & Azad Jammu & Kashmir. In this sense, the Ex-FATA barely managed to become a part of the “varna” – the constitutional territories’ club – but where it lies in the hierarchy was made clear even very recently by the cuts in quotas for students.

In the case of Gilgit-Baltistan, some commentators and many local people believe that the place and ecology are geo-strategically and economically desirable but the people, the naïve natives, are expendable. If this is true, the people of Gilgit-Baltistan are kept less politically human, just like the Dalits are considered less human socially, although the social and political are derivatives of the economy and obviously intermeshed in material reality.

Moreover, just as the untouchables were restricted to occupations undesirable for the Varna castes (though many of them still remain restricted to these jobs despite the law even now), the people of Gilgit-Baltistan and Azad Jammu & Kashmir are kept in their place which was decided for them and not by them. They still wait for democratic and political rights/representation until the resolution of the Kashmir issue. Especially, in the case of Gilgit-Baltistan, whereas Azad Jammu & Kashmir enjoys nearly autonomous status, it has only been a decade since any legislative and governance authority was given to the people of Gilgit-Baltistan even if through a largely powerless Gilgit-Baltistan Assembly (GBA). They were kept untouchables effectively, out of sheer disregard for the people’s rights as humans.

Gilgit-Baltistan is riddled, for an observer, with two kinds of predicaments, to reiterate. The first is Structural – the state as the perpetrator – the second is internal divisions. Obviously, both complement each other to perpetuate the status quo and in more insidious colonial projects. As the Structure is linked internationally to the Kashmir issue and there is vibrant work on it. Therefore, I will focus on the internal repellers to political emancipation.

There are more pervert and pernicious similarities amongst the sub-continental ‘untouchables’ and northern untouchables, so to speak. These similarities are to be found among most oppressed people really. Under oppressive structures which normalize them over time, the ideology of the system creeps into the oppressed groups and creates internal fissures.

There are more than 50 sub-castes inside Dalits; they find it hard to unify, in order to, break the yoke of casteism because some Dalits deem themselves superior to other Dalits. Similarly, narrower identity groups in Gilgit-Baltistan deem themselves unique or superior to others. The political epoch demands unity and solidarity amongst different ethnicities and sects in order to overturn the status quo, reject whimsical presidential orders, resist the arbitrary land encroachments, and in short defy internal colonialism or what one scholar has termed as postcolonial colonialism. The people break themselves between ethnicities or sects. Why? We must ask.

The irony or obscenity in Gilgit-Baltistan is this ‘clash of cultures’ on a domestic level which is more lethal to the political question than the state as the perpetrator and exploiter. This brings us to the question, ‘what constitutes a nation?’ We go with the simplest definition that it is a group of people politically and economically interlinked.

Nation – not in a sense of a state-orchestrated by common beliefs and negotiated reality with boundaries which are least desirable for the people – already exists whether anyone notices or not, but the absence of acceptance of this definition as people with same vows and griefs in popular consciousness will render perpetuating status quo or usher in a new more sinister internal colonialism. The people of Gilgit-Baltistan, I reiterate, need to consider this definition. In the material world, everything else is just bourgeoisie ideology and appropriation.

Why have the people of Gilgit-Baltistan, not been able to unite on the question of identity or political rights 70 years on?

Sectarian element:

Scholars believe that the Cold War is to blame for the sectarianism in Pakistan. When the USSR was to be defeated, the CIA and ISI cropped up the Jihad culture. And we haven’t still hit the bottom of sectarianism. Many nationalists and Left activists have been sloganeering relentlessly against political alienation and economical exploitation in Gilgit-Baltistan since the 1980s. Johar Ali, Haider Shah Rizvi, Ehsan Advocate, Baba Jan, and numerous veteran leaders harbored political resistance against total alienation.

Some voices were nipped in the bud, incarcerated and some are still receiving threats. The religious orientation of a leader plays a vital role inside Gilgit city. Other districts are not diverse compared to Gilgit city. The textbook example of colonial ‘divide and rule’ is still conspicuous and renders itself effective in every election. Constituency GBA-1 has been plagued with this despicable sectarian politics in the last 3 or 4 elections.

On November, 16, never have anyone seen the extreme hatred against the ‘otherized’ community was sensationally tangible. Pre-poll rigging, During-poll rigging, and every other rigging were the means to defeat the other community – or the aspirant of other sects. Obviously, there were invisible hands with whims to dictate the electoral results or these hands miraculously determine the victory of the blue-eyed boy, nonetheless, this boiling hatred against each other, which is no doubt deeply embedded in society, is indicative of a problem of the popular consciousness. This vulnerability makes us what we are today.

In the recent tragic incident at Naltar, people rushed to label the act of terrorism as sectarian violence. The Nationalists and the Left-wingers jumped to the conventional conclusion of the invisible hands functioning backdrop in order to divide and encroach the land. Both conclusions are unpersuasive and absurd taken separately. Why? Because we are reducing the causal factors of the political landscape too narrow. Of course, both explanations are, to a certain extent, correct. But what we need to do is to accept both simultaneously: no clinging to only one. That is, there exists, both an element of animosity between groups culturally – whether nurtured and not – as well as the utilization of the divisions and conflicts proactively or opportunistically by political, economic, or bureaucratic entities.

Elite or NGO element:

Propaganda and conspiracy theories related to international sway in the region cannot be sidelined. Locals bidding for the Pakistani bourgeoisie buying and harboring them lands in exotic places like Nalter, Hunza, Astore and Skardu have also deep interest in maintaining the status quo.

The influx of domestic tourism after a new peaceful/pacified phase has got the elite in Pakistan to fancy the rare landscapes for much higher prices which cannot be resisted by lower-middle-class families trying to cope with the consumerist culture in a marginalized region. If by any chance anyone resists selling their property, it’s clear what may come to the – religious and political pressure and threats. Common land, meadows, and hills, which must be preserved by society not by the government in the façade of national parks, have been gradually seized by the state outsourcing the potentiality of resources like minerals and water bodies.

The NGO factor is becoming palpable. These organizations have monopolized economical, social, cultural, and religious influence all over Gilgit-Baltistan. Obviously, collectively these all translate into political actions – which are conformity to the status quo or rather an indifference. A whole set of work is needed to find the rationale behind NGOs but for this piece, I will, as Paulo Freire puts, simply say that NGOs are nothing but a façade of elites offering their false generosity.

Culture:

This, again, brings us to the question of internal exceptionalism. The latter means a sense of superiority to other communities or an ethnocentric/xenophobic worldview. I don’t want any trouble being specific. Every sect and ethnic group in Gilgit-Baltistan has differences relative to another across culture, political worldview, and ideology. No matter how much we try to hinder the argument that we don’t have separate cultures, especially the neo-educated ‘Yankees’ have this reluctant axiom publically. We have to accept that culture matters for an ordinary man/woman in Gilgit-Baltistan.

The more, as Freud would agree, we feel we are not, the more we are. The irony is that there is no issue being different, but the Nazi-like attitude for ‘others’ is the center of this predicament. This exceptionalism with being ignorant and devoid of clarity about other communities, their beliefs, and symbols constitutes propaganda and conspiracy theories about each other and ultimately translates into political fragmentation. To prove my point, in our childhood we used to label red ants as ‘us’ and black ants as ‘others’. It’s a shame that hundreds of innocent ants were killed in the mane of this brainwashing-from-the-cradle mechanism. We have been fighting someone else’s war. Slitting throats, we have spilled our own blood.

What’s the answer?

Therefore, the common ancient culture orchestrated by aesthetics – music, dance, folk stories, and mythology – has also been obfuscated by this obscene sectarianism, needs to pitch in asap. It’s really hard or impractical for a man/woman from a different sect to celebrate the symbols and festivals of another sect. It can be possible in the future but obviously not today. For Hegel, a 19th-century German philosopher, aesthetics, especially music, is the greatest healer of the ‘wound of nature’. A society that is not only wounded but plagued by utmost absurd divisions needs also music to get healed. We all know that music has opened the ways for social cohesions and for a platform where people can not only tolerate and understand diversity but accept it.

Politically motivated art, especially music, has done some serious damage to popular ignorance. The spring festivals, too, celebrated recently all over Gilgit-Baltistan is a sign of hope. The problem with the Left today, who is single-handedly holding this burden of freedom and honor, is their stark negligence of culture/aesthetics as a potential common denominator or means to unify the scattered. The Left must create an environment that caters to everyone. Where everyone feels at home and struggles for the horizon.

Light, at the end of the tunnel, is boasting, encouraging, being creative, reviving, and sharing this common heritage of aesthetics, music especially. Otherwise, I am a pessimist like Slavoj Zizek that the light at the end of the tunnel is basically the light of another turbulent train coming towards us but not whistling.

Irfan Kazmi

Irfan Kazmi studies politics and sociology at Forman Christian College Lahore. Eternally fascinated about the national question of Gilgit-Baltistan, writing has been his way of thinking and resistance. He aspires to cover themes like poverty, patriarchy, absurdism, and politics.

Comments

Blogs

The Price of a Sigh

Published

3 years ago

October 26, 2021

Irfan Kazmi

Markus Spiske

She opened her eyes before the break of dawn as it was her sheer routine from the day of her wedding. She was just fifteen when a man in his late forties sent his marriage proposal to her mother, ironically she didn’t even remember her father who passed away long before she could even talk.

Now, she was married for 25 years and the terrors of existence had long encompassed her life in every both sane & illogical ways. She lost 11 nascent babies repeatedly, as her husband used to put, “You are damned from the heavens.” The days after the marriage was the butterfly phenomenon for the hell of a storm to come.

Her husband lost his job as a gatekeeper for a landlord, his knees were making him unfit and in deep pain where he had to be on regular medication which has also become a catalyst to make him dizzy and intoxicated all the time. It was like a tradition for her to have a child and lose him/her in just a couple of days. Had her husband been just 5 more years younger than his actual age, his family would have managed to make another teenage girl’s life miserable.

Fortunately, after 25 long years of this ominous and tedious tradition, the heavens took mercy on her despair, she gave birth to a healthy Babyboy. This was her first sigh in 25 years, the most anticipated sigh after paying a staggering price of humiliation, sleepless nights, void mornings, experiencing exponentially the pain of giving birth & waiting for her progeny to die – she could only watch helplessly – and the Sisyphus’stone like days of labor.

Rabab jumped out of her bed, pushed herself up despite stone-heavy eyelids, she wanted to sleep but the baby started to cry out-load. She always said to herself – to give herself an excuse to wake up – “One day, I will sleep for eternity, but not now.” Luckily, the baby again went to sleep after some lullabies and cradling. She had neglected her body pleading to rest but she pushed it beyond its limits, as that was the only option.

Her husband was snoring loudly as he didn’t even give a *** about this phenomenon called life & its angsts. She prepared herself to offer the morning prayers, when she thought about God, his blessings, and his trials, Rabab always asked Him, “Why! …. why me God!” and there, as usual, was nothing could she hear back. When she was a child, her mother used to tell her, “God is always there to help; he is nearer than the heart, should any pain come to you, just ask Him to pitch in.”

She called Him over and over again to weigh in, not that she always complained about the pain, there was no other life she could compare to, where there were torrents of milk and honey. Rabab was just anxious about the life of her boy who was her everything to infinity and beyond. On Janamaz, her life was sailing, wandering and pinching her heart deep, anguish there was and all else was inexplicably abysmal void. Her tears were long to become dry, the sigh after that & sharing the existential suffering with someone beloved has long been squeezed and twisted in her throat.

Rabab’s daily drill as the sole breadwinner for the family was already, of course, a hell of a task, ironically some months ago her mother, a widow in her late 60s, was clinically pronounced paralyzed. She could not even straighten her arm on her own. Thus, Rabab had to be, simultaneously, a father to make a living, a mother to take care of her 2-month-old, and an obedient daughter to look after her mother.

She, after preparing breakfast and feeding a cow, went to a nearby school to clean the classes before the students’ arrival. After that, she gets to go and forth, to home and school to check on & feed her baby and husband too. Then at 2, she has to go to another school to do the same. In the evening she gets back home to prepare the next meal for her family. And then, the price to exist never fades away, Rabab had to go to her mother’s to feed and clean her.

She was fortunate enough to see her boy living; who were her only wish, dream, and hope…. obviously, hope is a dangerous thing that only prolongs the suffering. One day, out of nowhere her mother died, the irony, not the biggest perhaps, was that she didn’t even have any relatives or resources for her burial. The existence kept on demanding from her everything possible, not that only life was a pain but the society and its conventions.

The price of a single sigh kept on staggering at every crossroad. Rabab had to do all the things unwaveringly, she had not to be a person, a human, but a heartless and painless abstract living thing to attach all the strings of her life. After her mother, she had one task out of her daily basket, but her body exacerbated day by day, both the love of her mother, who was always there to hear her anguish and suffering, was not there to do that anymore and her worsening health, were pushing her to collapse, nevertheless, she waged the relentless unending war with her body.

That was the hottest day of the summer, Rabab was lost somewhere busy watering her vegetables. There was no shadow, alone under the scorching ruthless sun. She started to hallucinate…she dreamt herself in a desert desperate for a drop of water. She was wandering aimlessly, with every second the thirst is more severe, she had to find water, nothingness was all there and the ocean of sand.

She started to run, with that, her heartbeats freakishly, she is now on the top of a hill of sand, there is nothing in the millions of miles, suddenly the sand engulfs her… she fades away, her body is contracting and squeezing itself, she tried to find out what is happening but she couldn’t, she lost her consciousness and left alone under the firing sun, no one was around… She is going deep into the bottomless abyss, the breath, the closest friend forsakes her and she can not breathe…… she wants to have that last desperate sigh.

Blogs

A Youth-led Development Agenda for Gilgit-Baltistan

Published

3 years ago

June 26, 2021

Riaz Akbar

Gilgit-Baltistan’s development profile is remarkable by many standards. Modernity’s thought and systems made an entry to the secluded mountainous region only recently — the 1980s to be exact. Since then, it has witnessed changes in every stratum of life, revolutionizing the rural landscape, public health, education, and the people’s availability and receptiveness to new modes of thinking, some of them quite radical given the conservative core of the local cultures. The development pace was so rapid that in many cases social antibodies to change were not afforded enough time to block neo-liberal economic development.

One of the markers of modern development, according to Karl Deutsch, is the scale of social mobilization, and Gilgit-Baltistan’s social mobilization is quite a feat; it has broken the people out of the traditional model of economy and society and has made a transition into modernity. Judged against the 1970s baseline, Gilgit-Baltistan’s development along this dimension is electrifying. Needless to mention, GB’s first development wave was triggered and spearheaded by the Aga Khan Rural Support Program (AKRSP), one of the pioneers of the non-government rural initiative.

A second development wave appears knocking at Gilgit-Baltistan’s destiny today: a highly educated workforce in the Information and Communications Technology (ICT) industry, filled with enterprising spirit and ideas is loath to settle for a low paying, dead-end job in the government — as was the case with the previous generation. The new youth bulge that makes up 64% of the 1.5 million population, bravely experiments with entrepreneurship, generates revenue, and provides employment, while at the same time dreaming about even loftier goals. Small entrepreneurs and startups play a fundamental role in modern economies. It was the small entrepreneurs who earned China the global leadership position in economic development. People tend to dismiss or forget the fact that the rise of the US too was powered by small entrepreneurs.

Does the Gilgit-Baltistan Government understand the criticality of the moment? Will it rise to its call? Failing to do so will not just be an opportunity wasted but an issue of incalculable social and political disaffection and disorder. A lukewarm response or misreading of the opportunity will doom Gilgit-Baltistan for a long time.

There is hope though, as the new chief executive, Mr. Khalid Khurshid, is, perhaps, the first youngest chief minister of Gilgit-Baltistan in its history and one who is educated in the West. He understands the main drivers of development. He has already shown an impressive understanding of Gilgit-Baltistan’s issues and won grants and projects from the Federal government on an unprecedented scale in its history. It is with that hope, I will be spelling out a youth-led development agenda for Gilgit-Baltistan in a series of articles in the weeks and months ahead.

To begin with, I outline four areas in the private sector of youth-led trades/industries which can kick start Gilgit-Baltistan’s economy and increase the whole pie of the budget, without big “ifs” of investment and legislation. In subsequent articles, other important dimensions of development will be discussed.

The private sector in any country is crucially useful for two purposes; (a) generation of revenue in the form of direct taxes, and (b) creation of employment which increases spending in the economy further generating revenue. But for that to seamlessly come about, some actions are warranted by the government.

Specialized Marketplaces in Gilgit-Baltistan

Cash crops, fruits, and dry fruit

Having a complex market landscape is one sign of a strong and well-developed economy. The more complex an economy, the more differentiated and specialized it becomes. In most cases, Gilgit-Baltistan’s economy and its many facets are in a developing phase. At the bare minimum, the government must establish specialized markets for different trade forms. Let’s for example, consider the market for cash crops and dry fruits.

The average annual output of cash crops, fruits, and dry fruits in Gilgit-Baltistan is estimated at a whopping 15–20 billion rupees, as per Gilgit-Baltistan government statistics. Another striking feature of Gilgit-Baltistan, unlike the rest of the country, is that 90% of people own land, and are directly associated with agriculture compared to just 52% of the national average. It is the quickest and most reliable source of income for most families in Gilgit-Baltistan.

The marketplace is necessitated by another glaring statistic: 73% of Gilgit-Baltistan’s population is either severely or moderately food insecure compared to the national average of 36% percent (National Nutrition Health Survey). Several factors are attributed to food insecurity including high food wastage and issues of physical access. According to the Zarai Taraqiati Bank (ZTBL), 45% of apricot — the region’s biggest fruit — is wasted every year; 10% of potato — the second biggest cash crop — also goes down the drain. Around 169,000 tons of fresh and dry fruits are produced of which 57,178 tons are wasted. Of the 152,000 tons of vegetables produced in the region, 12,000 tons go to waste. Only 26% of Gilgit-Baltistan’s population having guaranteed physical access and financial capacity to have nutritious food for a normal, healthy, and active life, which according to FAO, is egregious. The beggars believe that no government has sounded the alarm bell on the issue, much less taken concrete action to meet the challenge.

The marketplace must, therefore, have the provision of cold storage, safe transportation along the entire value chain, quick and standard transactions between growers, suppliers, and retailers quickly and efficiently. This will give industrial structure to this trade. Additionally, food packaging and branding on international standards of hygiene and good practices will help in the value addition of these products. Some of the fruits with longer shelf life can be exported with proper certification systems at this facility. Within a few years, the incomes of people can be tripled with a healthy impact on the overall state of Gilgit-Baltistan’s economy. This is also a profitable stream of revenue for the government when the taxes are imposed.

Special Technology Zones / IT Hubs / Technology Parks in Gilgit-Baltistan

According to Arif Habib Limited, a leading financial services firm, Pakistan exported IT services worth $213 million this year. Technology products of $1.5 billion were exported which is 35% of Pakistan’s tertiary sector. Gilgit-Baltistan can make significant contributions to that pool. With bare minimum investment, the highly talented IT graduates can leapfrog this industry. Gilgit-Baltistan’s two universities churn out IT graduates every year and more Gilgit-Baltistan origin IT graduates at Pakistani universities are sent to market every year. These talented youth are forced to live in expensive cities, away from their families, just for a reliable power supply and fast, stable internet.

Creating a single market in two divisional headquarters will bring in huge amounts of foreign exchange and expand employment opportunities for the youth, especially for the women as moving to cities for a job is harder for girls. The flow of revenue is going to be immense when compared to the investment required of the government. According to Shaan M. Khan, an IT entrepreneur from Gilgit-Baltistan, and CEO of two startups, uConnect, and uExel, the five-year turnover of the industry could reach $100 million if the government takes interest in the industry. Gilgit-Baltistan’s young IT entrepreneurs and freelancers based out of Gilgit and Skardu brought in about Rs. 200 million just last year while facing load-shedding of over 21 hours a day during winters and with the snail’s pace internet.

As long as Gilgit-Baltistan remains a tax-free zone, it presents an added incentive to set up startups in Gilgit. Since 2015, GB’s peace has largely returned and with low costs of a living, clean environment, it can even pull national companies to set up their outlets in Gilgit. Given Gilgit-Baltistan’s low population, even incomes in low IT services are a boon for the local economy. IT services that can be sold in such categories as web programming, app development, e-commerce, digital marketing, and data analytics can be harnessed for fighting unemployment.

Marketplace for General Services

The biggest service sector of Gilgit-Baltistan is the transportation sector. At the baseline of the 1970s, Gilgit-Baltistan’s transportation sector was non-existent, which forced the government to intervene and create the NATCO — Northern Areas Transportation Corporation, the only public sector transport service in Pakistan that’s still running successfully. Since then, it has become the largest asset holding corporation of Gilgit-Baltistan. And yet, most of the industries require a major upgrade in terms of quality, reliability, safety, and speed. These associated services and the core of transportation will add billions of more rupees to Gilgit-Baltistan’s economy.

Another sector where services are required is the investment sector. A sizable local capital is invested in unproductive and rent-seeking investments that slow down growth for want of better investment counsel. In an economy as small as GB’s — a total of around Rs. 100 billion, an investment of Rs. 10 billion is an enormous 10% of its entire economy. That’s only possible if excellent professional services are developed by the government of Gilgit-Baltistan. The onset of the Corona pandemic has vastly increased the scope of remote work which also provides great vistas for Gilgit-Baltistan.

Another area of professional services that can go big is the consultancy led by the local youth. More Gilgit-Baltistan youth now enter into premier national educational institutes like IBA, LUMS, NUST and are educated in the West, especially in the US and the UK as a result of the Fulbright and Chevening programs. These young professionals can fill in with world-class services in educational reform, innovations in agriculture, finance, governance, and industries that the traditionally weak government departments cannot deliver. New services built on digital platforms will generate employment, revenue, and more importantly a growth-led development role for the youth.

Another potentially high revenue and employment generating industry is that of entertainment. There are no local production houses, dedicated channels, and studios working directly on locally produced and local context-specific movies, serials, documentaries, game shows, etc., etc. Gilgit-Baltistan electronic news and entertainment sector is absent. The popularity of the few web channels hosted on Facebook and YouTube indicates there is a big demand for locally produced news, analysis and entertainment services. The most popular of those programs are the ones that are related to entertainment.

Of course, much of this has to start with the provision of easy access to finance for youth. Since youth hold no property against which to secure loans, the government will have to come up with alternative methods to grant loans safely. These soft loans quickly and on large scales will inject the needed investments into the dedicated specialized marketplaces discussed here.

In aid of these ideas, documenting and digitizing the economy will have additional positive effects on growth and economic development. It will provide a comprehensive understanding of the structure and scope of Gilgit-Baltistan’s economy. Digitization drives will face roadblocks in the form of businesses and purple’s resistance, assuming it to be a trap for the tax net, which is a politically sensitive issue in GB. The government must dispel such apprehensions by arguing that such efforts are required for providing trade and industry-specific incentives — even baby steps towards that objective will be a welcome development.

A confluence of factors — availability of highly educated youth and a government led by a young chief minister — is at GB’s doorsteps. One can only hope, Gilgit-Baltistan’s government is aware of the momentous occasion.